So you want to be a co-author, eh?
Writing a short story or novel with someone else is something that can not only be a lot of fun but is also a great learning experience. Over time, we develop a writing style and eventually we get trapped into that writing style. This has a lot of advantages, but it has some disadvantages too such as concealing from you another way to present information. When we write with a co-author, it forces us to get outside of our comfort zones and adapt to a new writing style.
But, I’m not here to talk about the advantages of having a co-author. I’m here to talk about your rights and duties as a co-author. For the most part, this is just meant to be educational; unless you realistically believe your novel will be published, you have nothing to worry about. I’m going to cover (1) what makes a co-author, (2) copyright, (3) rights of a co-author, and (4) duties of a co-author. Fun!
What Makes A Co-Author?
So first, what makes a co-author? If you and your friend both actively decide to be co-authors and write the work together, then the answer is obvious. But what about when you post your story on YWS and someone suggests to add a paragraph. Does inserting that paragraph make the person a co-author? 95% of the time, the answer is no.
For the remaining 5% of the time, you have to take a look at a few things. Lets say the story is only two paragraphs long to begin with. Adding a third paragraph extends it by 50% (encompassing 33% of the new work). That sounds pretty substantial. So one way to judge if someone is a co-author is to look at how much they contribute.
Another (and more popular way) is to look at the intent. Did both people intend to be co-authors? If the paragraph is suggested as part of the review process, then the answer would be ‘no’.
Yet, there are tricky areas still. Suffice to say that for your purposes that unless you both agree explicitly to be co-authors, you shouldn’t worry!
Copyright!
Two people write a short story. Who owns the copyright? The answer is, both. When you have a co-author, both of you hold a copyright in the entire work. Keep in mind that a copyright is automatic these days, so there’s no need to register the copyright.
Rights of a Co-Author
Since both co-authors own the copyright, do they need permission from one another to use the work? Not at all. If you are a co-author you can publish the work, sell it, whatever without permission from the other co-author. The only thing you can’t do is allow someone else to publish it exclusively. What that means is you can’t say to HarperCollins (a publisher): “Only you and you alone will publish this.” To do that, both co-authors need to give their permission. Or in the case of several co-authors, a majority is necessary.
Duties of a Co-Author
That sounds pretty extreme; your co-author can do anything with the work without your permission? Here’s the catch though: your co-author has a duty to account. That means if your co-author profits, then he/she must share those profits 50/50 with you.
As with my other articles on copyright, this is very brief and is meant to just be very basic. If you have any questions, let me know in the comments.
So, if someone published a storybook, would the profit of the story go to all it’s members.
Also, what if a co-author publishes without giving credit to the other author?
My co-author and I work on stories together as well as write on our own; solo. When it comes to publishing our separate, un-co-authored work, are there any stipulations? If she were to submit her work to an agent/publisher and that agent/publisher wanted an exclusive, yet a month later we were ready to farm out our co-authored MS, could we still do that ?
Christy, I think you answered your own question! If your agent/publisher wants an exclusive and both of you and your co-author agreed to that, then it’s exclusive. Exclusive means it can only be used by one party. So, you could not farm it out.
Kamas, your first question has zero chance of happening in the real world. But to answer it, of course the profit would go to all it’s members. The share of the profits, though, would have to be diddyed up according to the amount of work produced. Deciding that would be a decision left to the people involved. And if a co-author publishes without giving credit, then that’s obviously wrong as well. If there’s money involved, then sue. Otherwise, it’s just an issue of morality.
Though it has zero chance, I was just wondering. Thanks Nate ^^
Thanks for the response! I just wanted to clarify. So- if she has her own material on the side and found an agent who wanted an exclusive on THAT MS… yet we’re co-authoring something entirely different, and we wanted to still query other agents with this other MS.. are you saying we cannot do both at the same time even if the MS’s are different in that respect??? Are you saying we have to wait on her solo MS to either sink or swim before we can query our independent, co-authored MS?
Why is there a zero percant chance of a story book being published? If all the co-authors mutually agree by meeting somewhere somehow and someone wants to publish it, is it not legal?
Jasmine: Legal but very unlikely. There’s a stage of polishing required before a novel can become publishable and that stage is difficult enough when there are two authors in the same room. When there are as many as ten across different countries, it’s practically impossible.
Christy: Your wording was a little awkward in the first question. If your friend agreed to an exclusive on her manuscript, it would not affect your joint manuscript. As long as it is just one manuscript she agreed to an exclusive on. The wording is very important. If she agreed to an exclusive on all writing contributed to by herself, so an exclusive on her as a writer, then your joint manuscript would fall under the terms. However, you would have to agree to that also.
Basically I think the answer you’re looking for is you can do both at the same time. It would be fine for you to continue to flog your joint manuscript while the other manuscript is submitted to an agreement.